Caithness Map :: Links to Site Map Great value Unlimited Broadband from an award winning provider  

 

Options Identified For Dealing With Particles In The Environment

5th November 2006

A panel of experts has identified a short-list of 11 feasible combinations of options for addressing the legacy of radioactive particles in the marine environment around Dounreay.

The options will be detailed for the first time tonight at the Environmental Research Institute in Thurso when Phil Cartwright (UKAEA) and Paul Dale (SEPA) will provide an update on the recent work undertaken to understand the extent of the contamination and the human health aspects respectively.

The panel recognised that recovering every particle was not possible and "an understanding of when the issue has been dealt with sufficiently" needs to be considered. The options therefore include differing degrees of clean-up of the seabed near Dounreay, from where particles buried in the sediment are carried by the sea onto nearby beaches.

Following public consultation earlier this year on the completeness of a list of options, revisions were made to the list and the assessment criteria. A total of 24 onshore and offshore options were identified.

In July, a scoring panel was established which included five independent members who provided expertise in health and safety, environmental, socio-economics, technical feasibility and regional issues. The scoring panel agreed the methodology for assessing the options and over an intensive three-day period assessed each onshore and offshore option separately. They then considered whether the options remaining could be combined to ensure an effective onshore and offshore option. The option combinations identified as feasible are:

Onshore monitoring with recovery plus offshore monitoring without recovery [current method]

Onshore monitoring with recovery plus offshore monitoring with recovery.

Onshore monitoring with recovery plus targeted recovery of detectable individual particles

Onshore monitoring with recovery plus recovering offshore particles by the targeted bulk removal of marine sediments.

Onshore recovery of all individual particles at all depths plus offshore monitoring with recovery.

Onshore recovery of all individual particles at all depths plus targeted recovery of detectable individual particles offshore.

Onshore recovery of all individual particles at all depths plus recovering offshore particles by the targeted bulk removal of marine sediments.

Onshore bulk removal of beach sediments plus targeted recovery of detectable individual particles offshore.

Onshore bulk removal of beach sediments plus recovering offshore particles by the targeted bulk removal of marine sediments.

Onshore restrict public access plus targeted recovery of detectable individual particles offshore.

Onshore restrict public access plus recovering offshore particles by the targeted bulk removal of marine sediments.

The detail of the options, as discussed by the panel, focus on monitoring the beaches and offshore areas local to Dounreay, including Sandside beach. Monitoring of local beaches outwith the local area will continue.

Full consultation with the public and stakeholders on the feasible combined options is now scheduled to take place in early 2007.

Phil Cartwright, Particles and Contaminated Land Manager, UKAEA said "UKAEA has taken a major step forward in identifying the long term management strategy for dealing with particles in the environment. We recognise this is of interest to a wide cross section of the community particularly those who have been most directly affected. We want to continue to consult to ensure we have everyone's views on a way forward which is both environmentally sound and publicly acceptable."

Geoffrey Minter, Sandside's proprietor, said: "Sandside is encouraged by what it regards as a constructive new attitude within the senior management of the UKAEA and Dounreay. It very much hopes that this more open and responsive approach will produce results soon and lead to a serious, long-term programme to return the local environment to its original pristine state. The publication of the BPEO Scoring panel result today is a step in the right direction. Like me, the Caithness public want to see a
professional clean up operation in the affected close vicinity of Dounreay. Action must be taken urgently to put this into effect. I stand ready to help in any way I can."

Particles were generated during the dismantling and preparation for reprocessing at Dounreay of spent nuclear fuel. There is evidence that some of these particles entered the drainage systems at Dounreay and were discharged to sea.

Lower activity particles have been detected and recovered during routine monitoring of the beaches used by the public at Sandside (70 particles) and Dunnet (1 particle). Higher activity particles have been detected on the foreshore at Dounreay and in the sediment offshore. Restrictions on fishing are in place in this area.

UKAEA is required to monitor a number of local beaches to criteria regulated by SEPA, when access is available to do so.

In March, SEPA published research into the potential health effects of particles typically found at Sandside. While there is potential for short-term visible effects to occur through skin contact, the chances of coming in to contact with a particle are extremely low.
See: http://www.sepa.org.uk/news/releases/view.asp?id=349&y=2006

The options have been identified as part of a study to determine if there is a better option to reduce the risk from particles than the current strategy of monitoring beaches.
See: http://www.ukaea.org.uk/sites/dounreay_particles.htm

 

Related Businesses

 

Related Articles

Design Contract Awarded For Dounreay Shaft And Silo WorkThumbnail for article : Design Contract Awarded For Dounreay Shaft And Silo Work
Dounreay has awarded an important waste clean-up contract to Jacobs as the site plans for the future of its deepest historic radioactive waste store.   Jacobs and its supporting partners have been awarded a 6-year contract to provide a design management team to produce a fully integrated design for the shaft and silo project.  
Radiation dose to public from Dounreay reducesThumbnail for article : Radiation dose to public from Dounreay reduces
Dounreay’s radioactive impact on the environment continues to fall, according to a report.  The annual survey report “Radioactivity in Food and the Environment” (RIFE 2012) has recently been published and it can be read here - http://www.sepa.org.uk/radioactive_substances/publications/rife_reports.aspx The report uses data obtained from samples of air, fresh water, grass, soil, and locally sourced meat, fish, milk and vegetables during 2012.  
57,000 Tonnes Of Hazardous Materials Finally Dealt With At Dounreay
Dounreay today completed the destruction of one of the most hazardous legacies of Britain's earliest atomic research.  A purpose-built chemical plant processed the last of 57,000 litres of liquid metal lifted from the primary cooling circuit of the experimental fast breeder reactor.  
Dounreay Dome Paint Job ScrappedThumbnail for article : Dounreay Dome Paint Job Scrapped
Bosses at Dounreay agreed that they won't now be spending £500,000 on a repaint of the sphere.   They money saved will go instead towards actual decommissioning work.  
Clean-up Reveals 6000 Years Of Human HistoryThumbnail for article : Clean-up Reveals 6000 Years Of Human History
Getting rid of Britain's 20th century experiment with fast breeder nuclear reactors is illuminating the history of human settlement on Scotland's north coast stretching back 6000 years.   Archaeologists hired as part of the closure of the nuclear site at Dounreay have pieced together the legacy left by previous generations who occupied the site as long ago as 4000BC.  
New Report Lists Radioactive Wastes At DounreayThumbnail for article : New Report Lists Radioactive Wastes At Dounreay
The Nuclear Decommissioning Authority has published the latest edition of the UK's radioactive waste inventory.   This sets out the type and volumes of radioactive waste at sites such as Dounreay, as of April 1, 2010.  
Nuclear Shutdown Cash Boost For School Skills
Cash from the closure of the fast reactor site at Dounreay is set to breed a new generation of engineers and scientists in the Scottish Highlands.   The money from the Nuclear Decommissioning Authority will fund half the cost of a £50,000 project to increase the number of school-leavers skilled in science, technology, engineering and maths.  
New Vaults Signal Start Of Waste ClearanceThumbnail for article : New Vaults Signal Start Of Waste Clearance
The clearance of tens of thousands of tonnes of radioactive waste from the redundant nuclear site at Dounreay today moved a step closer.   Dounreay Site Restoration Ltd announced the formal award of a contract to develop a disposal site for low-level waste from the decommissioning and closure of the site.  
Ex UKAEA Boss Appointed To Crown Estates Board
THE CROWN ESTATE REAPPOINTS CHRIS BARTRAM, AND APPOINTS DIPESH SHAH OBE AND ANTHONY WHITE AS NON-EXECUTIVE BOARD MEMBERS The Crown Estate has announced yesterday, 22 December 2010, the re-appointment of Chris Bartram and the appointment of Dipesh Shah and Anthony White as Non-Executive Board Members.   Chris Bartram, who has held the appointment as Crown Estate Board Member for four years has been reappointed for a further four year term with effect from 1 January 2011.  
Dounreay Boss Welcomed Funding Announcement
Dounreay Site Restoration Ltd recently welcomed an announcement about how much public money will be available to continue nuclear clean-up in the UK.   DSRL manages the closure of the site on behalf of the Nuclear Decommissioning Authority, which today confirmed that its total expenditure, including income generated, would be maintained at current levels of around £3bn a year.